PlaybookPlay 03

Raydium CPMM vs CLMM and Which Pool a New Token Should Open

Read time
7 min
Sections
10
Updated

On the question of Raydium CPMM vs CLMM, a new token should almost always open a standard pool (CPMM). It covers every price from zero upward, takes one deposit and needs no management. A concentrated pool (CLMM) can do more with the same capital, but only inside a price range that someone has to choose and keep adjusting, and a new token's price rarely stays where anyone expects. The rest of this page explains the difference so you can tell whether your case is the exception.

How a standard pool (CPMM) works

A standard pool holds two balances, your token and SOL, and prices every trade so that the product of the two balances stays constant. That single rule gives it liquidity at every possible price. The pool cannot run out of range, because it has none.

What you get as a liquidity provider:

  • One deposit. Both sides go in at a ratio that sets the starting price. The arithmetic is in how initial liquidity sets the starting price.
  • Fungible LP tokens. They arrive in your wallet as an ordinary token and represent your share of the pool.
  • Fees that compound. Trading fees are added to the pool's reserves. You collect them when you redeem LP tokens, as part of your share.
  • Nothing to manage. The position is the same on day one hundred as on day one.

The price of that simplicity is capital efficiency. Most of the liquidity sits at prices the token may never trade at.

How a concentrated pool (CLMM) works

A concentrated pool lets each provider choose a lower and an upper price and place liquidity only between them. Inside the range, the same capital gives traders much deeper liquidity than a standard pool would. Outside it, the position does nothing.

What changes for you:

  • A position NFT instead of LP tokens. Each position is tied to its own range.
  • Fees accrue to the position. They do not compound. You claim them.
  • Out of range means out of work. If the price leaves your range, the position earns no fees until the price comes back or you move the range.
  • The mix shifts completely. At the top of the range the position holds only SOL. At the bottom it holds only your token.

Raydium's pool type guide puts it plainly: concentrated liquidity rewards active management, and the extra fee income depends on rebalancing.

Raydium CPMM vs CLMM side by side

Standard pool (CPMM)Concentrated pool (CLMM)
Price coverageEvery price, alwaysOnly the ranges providers choose
What you holdFungible LP tokensA position NFT per range
Deposit at launchBoth tokens, at the starting ratioDepends on the range; can be one-sided
Trading feesAdded to reserves, collected on withdrawalAccrue per position, claimed separately
UpkeepNoneRanges need watching and moving
Raydium creation fee0.15 SOL, plus account rentNo protocol fee, rent only
Fee tierChosen at creation, fixedChosen at creation, fixed
Permanent lock (Burn & Earn)SupportedFull-range positions only
Best fitNew and long-tail tokens, passive liquidityStable or correlated pairs, managed liquidity

What each one costs to open

The figures below come from the Raydium fee reference and can change, so check them before a launch.

A standard pool pays a creation fee of 0.15 SOL to Raydium plus about 0.04 SOL of rent for the pool's accounts. Call it 0.19 SOL.

A concentrated pool pays no protocol creation fee. It does pay rent: about 0.06 SOL for the pool, more for the position, and more again for each tick array your range touches (the on-chain accounts that store price points). Wide ranges touch more of them. Raydium's guide for creating a concentrated pool suggests having about 0.3 SOL available for pool and position creation.

So the concentrated pool is not the cheap option it first appears to be, and the difference is small next to the liquidity you deposit in either case.

On BullToken the pool is a standard pool, and the launch panel shows the cost of opening it, Raydium's fee and rent included, before you sign.

Trading fees and how they reach you

Both pool types take a trading fee from every swap, set by the fee tier the creator picks. Raydium publishes the available tiers on chain. In practice a standard pool for a volatile new token usually sits at 0.25% or 1%, and concentrated pools run from 0.01% for stable pairs up to 1% for long-tail ones. In both designs the fee tier cannot be changed after creation.

In both, 84% of each trading fee goes to liquidity providers and the rest to the protocol.

The difference is in the delivery. A standard pool folds your share into its reserves, so your LP tokens slowly become claims on more of both tokens. A concentrated position collects fees in a separate balance that you claim, and only while the price is inside its range.

Why a new token usually wants the standard pool

The price has no history. Choosing a range means predicting where the token will trade. For a pair with a track record that is a judgment call. For a token that did not exist yesterday it is a guess, and a wrong guess leaves the position idle exactly when trading is busiest.

Launch days move far. A new token can go up several times over or fall most of the way to zero in hours. A full-range pool quotes a price the whole way. A range that looked wide can be left behind.

Wide ranges give the advantage away. The safe answer in a concentrated pool is a very wide range. Raydium's own guidance says a full-range concentrated position behaves much like a standard pool, with most of the efficiency benefit gone. You would be paying the complexity for little return.

Buyers and tools expect it. Fungible LP tokens are simple to verify. Anyone can see who holds them and whether they were locked or burned. Raydium's decision table sends long-tail and low-liquidity pairs to the standard pool, and its own token launchpad graduates tokens into standard pools.

Nothing to get wrong afterwards. No rebalancing, no claiming schedule, no position to forget about.

When CLMM is the better call

There are real cases for it.

  • A stable or closely correlated pair. If both tokens track the same value, a tight range captures nearly all the trading with a fraction of the capital. That is what concentrated liquidity was designed for.
  • You will manage it. A team with someone watching the price and moving ranges can earn more fees per SOL than a standard pool pays. Only while in range, and nothing guarantees it.
  • You want to launch with one side only. A range placed entirely above the starting price is funded with your token alone. SOL enters the position as buyers trade into it. This avoids putting up SOL at the start, at the cost of having no liquidity below the range and a position you must understand well.
  • A second pool, later. Once a token has a price history, adding a concentrated pool beside the standard one is a reasonable step. The two can exist together.

If none of those describes you, open the standard pool.

A note on the legacy pool

Older guides describe a third option that needs an OpenBook market ID. That is Raydium's legacy AMM v4. Raydium's documentation points new pairs to the standard pool instead, and the permanent lock feature does not support the legacy design. You can ignore it for a new launch.

What BullToken opens

BullToken opens a Raydium standard pool across the full range, paired with SOL, and trading starts as soon as the pool transaction confirms. The panel names the pool type and its trading fee on the cost line, so you know what you are creating before the second approval. The full run is described in how to create a liquidity pool on Raydium.

One thing is the same in every pool type. Liquidity is exposed to price moves, and what you withdraw later can be worth less than what you deposited.

FAQ

Is CPMM the same as Raydium's standard pool?

Yes. CPMM stands for constant product market maker, and it is the program behind the pool Raydium's interface calls the standard AMM. It is separate from the legacy AMM v4, which is tied to an OpenBook market.

Can I convert a CPMM pool into a CLMM pool later?

No, there is no conversion. If you still hold your LP tokens you can withdraw the liquidity and open a concentrated pool with it, or simply open a concentrated pool beside the existing one. Liquidity that was burned or permanently locked stays where it is.

Which pool earns more fees?

A concentrated position can earn more per SOL because its liquidity is packed where trades happen, but only while the price is in its range and usually only with regular adjustment. A standard pool earns less per SOL and earns it at every price. Neither comes with a guaranteed return.

Does a CLMM pool need SOL at launch?

Not always. A range set entirely above the current price holds only the token, so it can be opened without SOL. The position then has no liquidity below its range, which is a real limitation for sellers.

Can one token have both a CPMM and a CLMM pool?

Yes. They are separate pools under separate programs, and a pair can have several. Trades are routed to whichever gives the better price for the size.